Writing a Scholarly Book Review or Critique

For examples, two sites engaged in scholarly book review online are and the . They do different things, but both add something to the review process. In the end, for me one key thing will be to develop ways for authors and reviewers to add something to the overall process. That will help in generating a more robust ecosystem.

How to Write a Scholarly Book Review | eHow

Scholarly Book Reviews - McHenry County College

Sp Com 350 Scholarly Book Review Assignment

Many of the Libraries' index scholarly book reviews. In fact, these databases are often the preferred way to find book reviews because they cover (or index) the peer-reviewed literature of a given discipline, and reviews published in peer-reviewed journals generally do the best job of situating books within wider disciplinary debates. For example, to find reviews of United States history books written by historians a user should search the library databases and/or . Keep in mind that most databases allow users to limit their searches to book reviews only.

How to Write and Publish Scholarly Book Reviews

H-Net provides full text scholarly book reviews, 1993 to date, in the humanities and social sciences. RSS feeds for numerous academic fields and sub-fields are .

Scholarly book reviews
Reviews in scholarly journals evaluate books and the research, theory, andmethodology therein. Scholarly reviews also discuss how the book relates toother books on the subject. These lengthy reviews allow readers to stay currentwith research and thought in their field even if it is outside their direct areaof interest and they are unlikely to read the entire book. Some of theways to locate scholarly book reviews in history are:Use the following MCC Library databases to search for scholarly book reviews. To access the databases from off campus, enter your myMCC login. Remember to select "peer reviewed," "academic source," or "scholarly source."Reviewing books isan essential part of the historian’s profession. History students are expectedto learn the discipline: to become historians. In order to review a book onhistory it is essential to have some information on the subject, the region,and the period. The bibliography in the book should supply you with referencesto sources with related information. Journals are also a good place to findthis information and to look for scholarly book reviews that will also help youunderstand the form, and give you an idea of what your review should look like.This article examines the status of the book review as a form of scholarly publication in the humanities, looking at the role and characteristics of humanities book reviews and at who writes them and why. It examines evidence for the influence and impact of book reviews in the humanities and makes suggestions for the future of the scholarly book review in an online information environment.
How to write scholarly book reviews for publication. Notes from the William and Mary Quarterly.

The Evolving Practice of Scholarly Book Reviews

These are also good sources for finding citations to scholarly book reviews. You may also need to use the library catalog to locate a copy of the journal containing the review in order to read it. Some popular databases available at Ohio State are:

Scholarly Book Reviews in Literature Journals as Collection Development Sources for Librarians

The Scholarly Book Review in the Humanities


A. You may feel uneasy aboutwriting a critique of a book on a topic you know very little about--that’squite natural. So, obtain some assistance before you begin your review bychecking what reviewers have said about the book. Checkscholarly book reviews in professional journals such as the , the , the , or any of the dozens of similar such publicationsavailable online from the JSTOR resource, at ,or check the numerous print journals in the field of history, located in theLibrary and Technology Center (LTC). Ask the reference librarian if youneed help!

B. Write the review inyour own words. Plagiarism is stealing and will absolutely not betolerated. If occasionally you find it necessary to use material from thebook you are reviewing, use quotation marks to indicate that it is not yourwork.
Also, should you read or refer toanother book review as you prepare to write your own, remember that anymaterial you use from this source must also be cited. Unsure aboutplagiarism? Always ask before you submit your work.

C. Use the English languagecorrectly. Grammar and spelling are a fundamental part of anywell-written review. You will be required to demonstrate an adequatecommand of edited standard written English. This means that excessiveerrors (in general, more than three per page) may result in the paper beingreturned for mandatory revision before it will be accepted. Takeadvantage of the spell- and grammar-check options offered by MicrosoftWord. Not sure how to use those tools? Ask for help at the IT HelpDesk, in the LTC.

Scholarly Book Reviews | Libya Analysis

Scholarly Book Reviewing in America - ProQuest

This article examines the status of the book review as a form of scholarly publication in the humanities, looking at the role and characteristics of humanities book reviews and at who writes them and why. It examines evidence for the influence and impact of book reviews in the humanities and makes suggestions for the future of the scholarly book review in an online information environment.